Blockchain is an emerging technology with the potential for improvement, expansion, growth and innovation. This evolving aspect of blockchain technology warrants excitement, with a tinge of caution thrown in for good measure. For this reason, consulting with a blockchain lawyer or cryptocurrency lawyer may prove reassuring.
This article will survey the developing regulation of the cryptocurrency, or virtual currency, industry. It will focus on U.S. federal and state regulatory efforts, which are a work in progress. Future newsletters will continually update these efforts, and report on significant international regulatory developments.
Often described as the wild, wild west, the cryptocurrency environment has belonged to modern-day moonshiners and gold miners; independent, anonymous, private investors thriving in an unregulated, investor-beware, high-risk-high-reward atmosphere. To the dismay of some, the growing popularity of virtual currency has grabbed the attention of regulators. The threat of regulation awakens familiar philosophical adversaries. For example, the IRS demands private information from investors to accurately collect taxes. The investors do not want to reveal private information. As a second, broader example, the government wants to regulate. Businesses, however, claim regulation stifles innovation, costs jobs, and cramps the market.
In addition, mainstream businesses, from major banks to the corner deli, are embracing virtual currency. ATM’s accept cryptocurrency. These companies apply their internal rules and regulations to virtual currency.
The review of the important regulatory efforts begins with a cautionary statement: Cryptocurrency impacts many fields of the law. If you plan to take your business into the world of virtual currency, please first obtain the advice of a virtual currency lawyer.
Let’s start in New York, the financial hub of the United States, then proceed through the federal agencies, Congress, and the courts.
VIRTUAL CURRENCY REGULATION IN THE STATES.
The State of New York regulates the virtual currency industry. These regulations do not apply to the individual investor. However, a virtual currency exchange cannot operate in New York without the permission of the Department of Financial Services.
A virtual currency business may obtain permission in one of two ways. It may obtain a trust company charter which allows it to act as custodian of customer funds like a bank. The DFS granted itBit, a virtual currency exchange, the first charter in 2015, making it the first fully regulated exchange in the U.S. It granted the second trust charter to Gemini Trust Company.
In the alternative, the business may acquire a so-called BitLicense. Out of 22 initial applicants, DFS had granted three licenses by the August 2017 application deadline. The first BitLicense was granted to Circle in 2015, the second to Ripple, and the third to Coinbase in 2017. Reportedly, the cost in time and dollars caused companies to drop out. According to an article in Coindesk, some members of the virtual currency harshly criticized the expensive licensing procedure while others praised the protection it provides consumers. Several exchanges left New York rather than go through the licensing process.
Nasdaq states that at least five other states have proposed legislation controlling some aspect of the virtual currency industry. The laws differ, and the differences illustrate the problems in regulating the industry. Based on comments from industry spokesmen, business prefers the proposed laws of Illinois and Florida and disapproves of California’s, which mimicked the New York law. According to the Columbia Science and Technology Law Review, several other states have passed, or have pending laws regulating the blockchain industry. At least indirectly, these laws may also affect the virtual currency industry.
VIRTUAL REGULATION IN THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT
The IRS, SEC, and various agencies with the Department of the Treasury have begun to regulate the virtual currency industry. Congress lags. Hopefully, as the maturation process continues, all interested parties, government and private, will agree upon a uniform definition of terms and a comprehensive set of regulations.
The IRS has spoken on the issue of cryptocurrency in its advisory and its enforcement voices.
First, in 2014, it issued its Virtual Currency Guidance. Importantly, it established that virtual currency shall be treated as property subject to capital gains tax for federal tax purposes and that payments made in virtual currency are subject to IRS information reporting rules.
Second, in November 2016, the IRS obtained a federal court order allowing it to serve a John Doe summons on Coinbase, Inc., requiring it to give the IRS all its user records related to virtual currency transactions. Since then, the IRS agreed to limit its request to records of transactions greater than $20,000, and some Coinbase users have intervened in the lawsuit to protect their privacy. The IRS claims only 802 people reported bitcoin transactions on their 2015 returns. It estimates 500,000 transactions took place.
This legal action continues in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California. Involved Coinbase users may have to choose between filing an amended return or risking substantial penalties if the IRS prevails.
In July, the agency issued a report stating that “offers and sales of digital assets by virtual organizations” are subject to federal security laws. The SEC directed this forward-looking report to companies seeking U.S. investors for an initial coin offering (ICO) of equity tokens.
The same day it also issued a detailed Investor Bulletin providing guidance and warnings to companies and individuals considering participation in an ICO.
On August 28, the SEC issued an Investor Alert to warn ICO investors about fraudsters who use the lure of new technologies to scam their victims. “These frauds include ‘pump-and-dump’ and market manipulation schemes involving publicly traded companies that claim to provide exposure to these new technologies.” A prudent potential investor should read both the Bulletin and the Alert.
Controller of the Currency (Treasury)
Keith Noreika, the acting Comptroller of the Currency, told those at a Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia event in October, that he was open to cryptocurrency exchanges applying for bank status and that he is considering a nationwide cryptocurrency exchange licensing program to avoid individual state licenses.
In July FinCEN fined BTC-e, a virtual currency exchange, $110 million for willfully violating U.S. anti-money laundering laws. Reportedly, the online, foreign-based money transmitter has ceased operation.
VIRTUAL CURRENCY REGULATION IN CONGRESS
Congress, the preeminent U.S. lawmaker, has been virtually absent from the regulatory process. In May, the Combating Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing, and Counterfeiting Act of 2017, which references digital currency, was introduced in the Senate. It awaits action in the Judiciary Committee. Also in May, the chairmen of three House and Senate committees sent the IRS a letter questioning its tactics in the Coinbase litigation.
If you are looking for an experienced cryptocurrency lawyer, please contact the business lawyers at the Ishimbayev Law Firm, P.C. at 1-212-220-6548 to schedule a free consultation.
This article, the first of several, gives you a broad view of cryptocurrency from its history to its present use, security, and regulations. Future articles will keep you current with this burgeoning means of exchange for investors, non-profits, and peer-to-peer businesses.
Is cryptocurrency the tech world’s logical successor to paper money? Historically, currencies have evolved to meet the needs of a changing world. Early ancient agrarian societies traded with goats and grains. Centuries later Egyptians and Greeks pounded precious metals into coins carved with identifying information. The Chinese began using paper money about 100 B.C., starting the paper trail to the present. Now, each country supports its paper money with the government’s creditworthiness.
With greater frequency, people leave home without cash except, perhaps, for a $100 bill tucked away for an emergency. Paper currency has been replaced by credit cards, electronic payments, and online banking. But these relatively low-tech innovations require a middle-entity, such as a bank or PayPal. Cryptocurrency uses advanced blockchain technology described as an incorruptible digital ledger of economic transactions. It is transparent, anonymous, and lacks a physical presence.
What is Cryptocurrency and How Does It Work?
According to Investopedia, “cryptocurrency s a digital or virtual currency that uses cryptology for security.” A unique long string of numbers, created algorithmically, identifies each transaction, which is simultaneously registered on a ledger shared by many computers in different locations. Each user has an encrypted account number which also measured in coins, such as a Bitcoin, not tied to the currency of any government. The value is set by the combined buy-and-sell activity of all account holders. Greater activity increases the value and decreased activity reduces the value. The value fluctuation creates investment opportunities.
Proliferating blockchain startups and established organizations are creating new uses for cryptocurrencies, which should enhance their investment allure. As blockchains, virtual currencies fit naturally with peer-to-peer blockchain-anchored organizations wanting to eliminate the middleman. As examples, the United Nations built a blockchain system using cryptocurrency to streamline support distribution to refugees and a UK non-profit has created Mycelia, a musical ecosystem to fairly distribute proceeds from music sales directly to musicians and production people.
Here is an example: Let’s say you win a prize paid to you in Bitcoins. To receive the prize, you must set up a Bitcoin account. You will get an account number. The prize will be transferred in virtual money to your Bitcoin wallet. You find a must-have piece of art for sale at OpenBazaar, a free, online-marketplace which buys and sells using Bitcoin. You transfer the sale price in Bitcoin to the OpenBazaar Bitcoin account. No middleman. No fees.
In addition, an impressive partial list of established companies worldwide from 1-800 Flowers to Zynga accept cryptocurrency.
Whether you are the owner of a small retail business or a multi-national tech startup, Ishimbayev Law Firm can offer you excellent legal counsel that will help to safeguard your business and support your operational growth. With industry-leading expertise in business and entrepreneurship, you can count on us whenever you need legal guidance for your business.
At Ishimbayev Law Firm, we practice a client-first approach. You will always have our listening ears before we recommend the most appropriate legal solutions for your needs. We also practice a fixed-rate fee structure, ensuring absolute transparency about the legal costs you will pay. You will never have to worry about cookie-cutter templates when you work with us, because we fully understand every client is unique and requires a customized suite of legal solutions. No case is too big or too small for our NY business attorneys to handle – so you can feel confident and enjoy complete peace of mind when you make ILF your preferred choice for legal services in New York.
Ishimbayev Law Firm is a boutique NY law firm that specializes in a wide range of practice areas where we counsel and represent clients across different industries. As a market-leading legal specialist for businesses, we provide customized legal solutions while staying extremely reliable and highly transparent. We are uniquely placed to help our clients resolve their most complex legal challenges, and can offer stellar value for both small businesses and multi-national corporations.